Defect of the Month

Bob WillisFlux becomes increasingly tenacious the longer it sits on the board.

This month our topic is not so much a defect as something to consider when running environmental tests before any destructive analysis on solder joints. The through-hole joints shown in FIGURES 1 and 2 were soldered with a high-temperature alloy as part of our trials on robotic laser and single point soldering. The amount of flux in high-temperature cored wire tends to be higher, hence more residues after soldering. If sample boards will be exposed to high-temperature storage, in this case 200°C for 1,000 hr., or temperature cycling, clean the residues first. It is much more difficult to clean after this level of aging, and mounting samples in epoxy for microsections is much more difficult.


Read more ...

Bob WillisInappropriately sized pads can result in excessive solder and, eventually, defects.

This month we show soldering of 01005 chip resistors from an early project with lead-free assembly. The microsection image in FIGURE 1 shows a few issues, but it’s the circles in both joints that caught my eye. Yes, they are voids before they are unmasked. During sectioning we stopped just before entering the void. Most would have continued a few more micros to remove the thin sliver of solder, which was the wall of the void, to show the void. But everyone has seen voids before!



Read more ...

Bob WillisSolvents in holes can heat and "pop."

This month we look at voids or missing conformal coating. Depending on the lack of coating and position, this condition may result in acceptance or rejection. Normally with conformal coatings, small voids not specifically associated with electrical termination or bridging connections are acceptable, depending on the level of inspection criteria.

FIGURE 1 shows voids or bubbles in conformal coating under UV dark light. I would suggest both these cases require rework, as the electrical termination points are exposed, and there is no protection. Most likely, solvent coating has run into the holes. As the coating starts its first transition from a liquid, the voids expand from the holes. Then they pop, leaving the surface or pads with no protection.

It is suggested too much coating was applied on one pass, and initial evaporation could not occur, resulting in a volcano-like reaction from the holes. Each of the holes associated with coating voids had limited solder fill or cavities. In the past, we have seen the same problem with selective coating around press-fit connectors.

Read more ...

Bob WillisA lack of compression can be seen nondestructively.

This month we look at crimp connections.

FIGURES 1 and 2 show examples of simple compression connections. Figure 1 shows an excessive length of stripped wire within the crimp termination and a total lack of any compression, which should be easy to see on the wire bundle from the point of entry to the point of compression. Figure 2 lacks compression of the connector, and the stripped wire is barely within the barrel of the connector.



Read more ...

Bob WillisTry this test to determine paste problems.

This month we look at solder paste slump during preheating. It is important to know how much, if any, of the paste slumps like butter on a hot day during reflow. If solder paste does slump, it can lead to shorts, solder balls or solder beads, or cause variations in solder joint volume on selected joints.

Variation in joint volume occurs when one joint acquires more solder from an adjacent joint during reflow due to the paste being linked. Testing of solder paste is well covered in IPC specifications, and equipment is available to test paste and record the results.

Alternatively, if you think you have an issue, a simple shop floor test is to use the existing profile but change the temperatures of the final reflow zones. Setting the final zones to final preheat temperatures will slow the degree of slump. Normally the maximum slump is seen earlier during reflow. Typically, as solder paste is changed or the metal particle size is reduced, slumping can be seen more often.

Read more ...

Bob Willis

Tricks to eliminate exposed copper.

This month we look at solder pad coverage. Some quality engineers still want to see solder coverage, regardless of the PCB surface finish. If they see the original surface coating, they become concerned, regardless of what is stated in IPC standards.

In the case of NiAu (FIGURE 1), it is most likely the solder paste will reflow and wet the pad toe area right up to the solder mask. In the case of an organic surface protectant (FIGURE 2), the solder paste will reflow successfully, wetting the termination and pad, forming a reliable joint. However, the solder may not reflow and wet any farther than the original print area on the OSP coating on the pad.


Read more ...

Page 1 of 10